top of page

Strength Training or Cardio: Which Should You Focus On?

Nov 2
5 min read
Strength Training or Cardio

“Should I focus on strength training or cardio?”


It’s one of the most common questions we hear.


And the answer is simple:


It depends.


That may not be the exciting answer, but it’s the right one.

The real question isn’t whether strength training or cardio is better. The real question is:


What do you need right now?


Do you have a basic foundation of cardiovascular fitness? Can you walk, climb stairs, or move through your day without getting completely out of breath?


Do you have enough strength to tolerate the activities you want to do?

Are you training for a sport? Trying to lose weight? Preparing for a race? Trying to stay independent as you get older?


Context matters.


Strength Training: Becoming Strong for Life


At Resilient Fitness, we talk a lot about being Strong for Life.


For most people, strength training isn’t about lifting the heaviest weight in the gym. It’s about developing functional movement, training the major movement patterns, moving in multiple planes, and building enough strength that everyday life feels easier.


We want you to be able to carry groceries, get off the floor, hike, play with your kids, work in the yard, travel, and keep doing the things you enjoy.


Strength also creates a foundation for many cardiovascular activities.


If you want to run, hike, play recreational sports, or complete longer endurance events, your muscles, joints, tendons, and connective tissues have to tolerate that work.


Cardiovascular fitness built on weak joints and tissues can eventually become a problem.


That doesn’t mean everyone needs to become a powerlifter. It means a stronger body generally has a greater ability to tolerate activity.


Cardio Is More Than Just Running on a Treadmill


When people hear “cardio,” they often picture a treadmill, bike, or long run.

But cardiovascular training can serve several different purposes.


Lower-intensity aerobic work can help improve recovery, build cardiovascular capacity, and increase your ability to tolerate harder training.


If someone is constantly sore, feeling beat up, or struggling to recover between workouts, sometimes adding easier aerobic work can actually help.


Then there is higher-intensity conditioning.


If you’re training for a trail race, playing weekend rec league soccer, preparing for a competition, or participating in another demanding sport, you may need higher heart-rate work and dedicated conditioning.


That might include intervals, running, biking, rowing, or even VO2-max-focused training.


The goal determines the method.


Your Strength Workout Can Also Build Conditioning


Strength and cardio aren’t always completely separate.


The structure of a strength workout can create a significant conditioning effect.


For example, when we use hypertrophy circuits, higher repetitions, shorter rest periods, or density-based training, heart rate goes up and work capacity improves.


You’re still lifting weights, but you’re also creating a metabolic and cardiovascular demand.


On the other hand, if we are training absolute strength, that looks very different.


You might perform a heavy set and rest three to five minutes before going again.


In that situation, we’re not trying to turn the strength work into cardio. We want you recovered enough to produce strength.


We can train conditioning separately later in the session.


That distinction matters.


What Does a Well-Rounded Workout Look Like?


For many of our clients who train two or three times per week, our sessions follow a fairly consistent structure.


We start with movement preparation.

That may include soft-tissue work, corrective exercise, stretching, activation, mobility, and nervous-system preparation.


From there, we move into the main strength exercise for the day.


After that, we typically use a hypertrophy-style circuit to build strength, muscle, stability, and work capacity.


Finally, depending on the person and their goals, we may finish with short conditioning intervals.


In one 60-minute session, we can train multiple physical qualities without randomly throwing exercises together.


Everything should have a purpose.


The Biggest Mistake: Random Acts of Exercise


One of the biggest problems we see is movement for the sake of movement.


People jump from workout to workout, sweat a lot, burn calories, and feel tired... but there is no clear progression.


Being exhausted after a workout does not automatically mean you improved.


Training requires a stimulus.


That stimulus needs to progress over time, and your body needs enough recovery to adapt to it.


At Resilient Fitness, we don’t train people just to burn calories.


We train people to get stronger, improve, and progress.


That requires the right stimulus and the right recovery.


Different People Need Different Things


This is where individualized coaching matters.


A 40-year-old parent trying to lose 20 or 30 pounds may benefit tremendously from simply increasing daily walking and overall movement while strength training a few times per week.


A 60-year-old who already hikes, walks the dog, and stays active may not need more cardio. That person may need more balance, power, coordination, and strength.


A recreational runner probably doesn’t need us to add more running. They may need stronger hips, hamstrings, quads, calves, core, and better ankle mobility.


A powerlifter may need the opposite. They already have a tremendous strength stimulus, so adding walking, aerobic work, or occasional conditioning can improve general fitness and recovery.


Someone who simply wants to be healthier probably needs a combination of all of it.


That is why the answer is rarely just “strength” or “cardio.”


Start With a Foundation


For most adults, I would rather build a foundation of strength and basic cardiovascular fitness before jumping straight into high-intensity cardio.


If you don’t have adequate tissue tolerance, strength, or basic cardiovascular capacity, intense conditioning can leave you feeling completely beat up.


That often creates soreness, frustration, aches and pains, and a negative relationship with exercise.


Instead, build the foundation first.


Get stronger.

Move more.

Build basic aerobic fitness.


Allow yourself to experience some of the low-hanging fruit of progress.


Then earn the right to train harder.


How We Decide What Someone Needs


When somebody first comes into Resilient Fitness, we spend a lot of time talking.


We want to understand training history, goals, lifestyle, injuries, activity level, and what they actually want to accomplish.


We also take clients through a quick six-movement assessment.


Once training begins, the assessment continues.


We look at strength, movement quality, fatigue, recovery, preparation, and how they respond to training.


Some people are what I call bridge clients.


We are helping bridge them from pain or inactivity into strength, cardiovascular fitness, and general physical preparation.


Other clients are performance-focused.


They may have a sport, race, competition, or specific goal.


The programming should reflect that.

Good coaching is an ongoing assessment process, not a one-time workout prescription.


So…Strength or Cardio?


Probably both.


The real question is how much of each you need right now.


Take an honest look at your training.


Are you actually getting stronger?

Are you improving cardiovascular fitness?

Are you just chasing calories?

Are your workouts progressing, or are you performing random acts of exercise?

Are you walking enough?

Are you recovering?


And most importantly, does your training match what you want your body to be able to do?


If you’re not sure, that’s exactly where good coaching can help.


At Resilient Fitness, we offer a complimentary No-Sweat Intro where we can sit down, talk through your goals, look at your training history, and help determine what your next step should be.


Because the goal isn’t just to work harder.


The goal is to train with purpose, recover, and keep progressing.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page